On 8 June 1967, during the Six-Day War, Israeli fighter jets and torpedo boats attacked a United States Navy ship, the USS Liberty, in international waters off Sinai. They killed 34 Americans and wounded 171. The assault lasted over an hour and left the ship burning and barely afloat. The United States never retaliated and barely acknowledged it, and 59 years later Congress has still never held a full public inquiry.

Israel claimed it had mistaken the ship for an Egyptian vessel, despite the large American flag flying in clear weather, the ship's unique silhouette and markings, and Israeli aircraft having flown over it earlier that same morning. Survivors, military analysts and NSA insiders have rejected that excuse. In 2003 an independent commission led by Admiral Thomas Moorer, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, found Israel culpable, and Moorer accused Johnson of covering up that the attack was deliberate. Ward Boston, chief counsel to the Navy's own court of inquiry, swore in 2004 that Johnson and his defence secretary Robert McNamara had ordered it ruled an accident.

Lyndon B. Johnson's administration rushed to accept Israel's apology. The Navy's court of inquiry was hurried and limited, and survivors were ordered not to talk under threat of imprisonment. Crewmen say the torpedo boats fired on sailors preparing the life rafts, and Boston said that testimony is missing from the released transcript. What could have been treated as an act of war was scrubbed from the national memory.

Washington made that choice for geopolitical reasons. By 1967 Israel was becoming a cornerstone of US strategy in the Middle East, the Cold War was raging, and Washington wanted to limit Soviet influence in Arab states and secure dominance over the oil-rich region. Justice for murdered US sailors was treated as expendable, and the lives lost on the Liberty became collateral damage in a relationship the government considered too valuable to risk.

One explanation for the attack is that the Liberty, a signals intelligence ship, was hit to stop it intercepting Israeli communications during the war, including over the alleged killing of Egyptian prisoners of war in Sinai. The NSA still keeps much of what it knows secret. If that explanation is right, this was a strike on a US ship to hide war crimes, and its motive has been buried along with the crime.

On 30 June 2026 Thomas Massie introduced a House resolution to honour the Liberty's crew and urge the declassification of every record of the attack. It has not left committee. Massie had already lost his Kentucky primary in May, after AIPAC's super PAC and two other groups backed by pro-Israel donors spent more than $15.8 million against him.

Every president since Johnson has chosen to look away, and every Congress has chosen not to act. The survivors, many of whom carried physical and psychological scars for life, were left to fight alone against both the trauma of the attack and the betrayal that followed.

The Liberty set the pattern for the US relationship with Israel, one in which an ally can kill Americans and the only response is deeper military cooperation. The same logic has covered Israel's role in arming apartheid South Africa, the genocide in Gaza and billions in military aid with no conditions, and it now has the United States fighting Trump's war on Iran alongside Israel. If the United States will not defend its own sailors from an allied power, it is telling every service member in uniform today that political alliances come first and their lives come second.

Thirty-four Americans died in broad daylight, and their government buried it. Never let anyone tell you it was an accident.